Is this ugly or What?

[R.K. Maroon]

That is a B&O tender - The trucks are SP tender Commonwealth. I think they also were used on B&O tenders.

I will vouch that the post-war Lobaugh USRA Light Pacific indeed came with those trucks, which indeed look like they came from a passenger car. These shots are from the files:

Lobaugh Pacific Tender 01.PNG (398.22 KiB) Viewed 6103 times

Lobaugh Pacific Tender 02.PNG (465.47 KiB) Viewed 6103 times

The original pre-war Lobaugh B&O Pacific had different trucks, if the catalog photo is to be believed:

Lobaugh B&O Pacific.PNG (195.32 KiB) Viewed 6103 times

[rex desilets]

Is the Lobaugh B&O Pacific supposed to be a P-1d?? Asking for a friend...

[bob turner]

I think so - I can check. Stauffer's B&O book is just out of reach.

[rrjjf]

Bob & all,

The prewar Lobaugh B&O Pacific was produced to look like the B&O P-1d locos. Those locos were built using boilers from older Mikados at Mt Clare Shops. They had a deep taper in their boiler but I think Lobaugh's boiler taper is excessive. I have a B&O published drawing in 1/4" scale of the P-1d and I really like these locos. I built a mechanism for one several years ago using correct 19 spoked drivers (B&O practice) I machined from Ken Henry iron castings. I have the Lobaugh tender shown above that was used on the locos. All of the photos I have seen of the real locos show the tenders with Andrews tender trucks.

Joe

[bob turner]

Joe - me wants photo . . .

[R.K. Maroon]

I have the diagram that Joe is referring to as well:



As I understand it, the B&O released a set of drawings for many of their models as a promotion to model railroading, probably associated with the B&O portable layout in some way (if nothing more than originating in the same marketing department). The drawings can be found in a book, Scale Modeling and the B&O Railroad, published by the B&O Museum. Here is a photo of the prototype, also found in the book on the same page:



I think Joe is correct -- the boiler taper on the Lobaugh model is a bit excessive.

Jim

[sarge]

If I was to hazard a guess, the excessive taper is to accomidate an oversized firebox to clear the motors of the day. A check of the height of the top of the box would tell if it was raised a bit for the motor (not uncommon; much like Lionel did with the cab of the scale Hudson making it look rather hideously out of proportion, for example). Then, the extra taper brings the boiler down to proper height and diameter at the courses forward.

A few minutes with a rule and a look inside would confirm that guess.

[Robert]

That is an exceptionally well proportioned locomotive I must say....a beauty.

Robert

[E7]

Best and Only had a LOT of nice stuff. I really like some of their first gen diesel color schemes.

Rich

[bob turner]

Not really a B&O fan, but I too like the early blue/black/grey schemes. I have a PA, E-7, and an FT AB in that scheme. The FTs are soon going back to Grande Gold or WP pumpkin soon.

Also have enough B&O 21" K-Lines to keep me happy!

Happy!

Back to the ugly D16 - new cab is finished. I shall try for photographic evidence.

[bob turner]

Jim - can you move those two photos together? I cannot grab them or I would do it. That way we can see how badly Lobaugh missed, and whether a better sand dome would help.

[R.K. Maroon]

Gladly:

P-1d Comparison.png (409.08 KiB) Viewed 5974 times

Note the consecutive numbers.

[Tom Dempsey]

To my eye it looks more like the Lobaugh is foreshortened, I'd measure the length against the prototype, that might be the answer.

[rrjjf]

It looks to my eyes that Lobaugh's transition in the boiler is almost twice as sharp as it should be. I like the look of the real P-1d but not the Lobaugh boiler.

Joe

[bob turner]

I will raise the sand dome on mine.

Here is the new cab. Changed the personality of this long-neglected model. It still needs to come forward a quarter inch.

image.jpg (305.62 KiB) Viewed 5967 times