Page 1 of 2

O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:17 pm
by SWrailroader
I have never seen anything like this before. It starts at the 23 sec mark in the video. What's next in this hobby?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_zUFzAuuRUs

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 9:59 am
by up148
Detracts from the presentation IMHO, but we're old, so maybe this is where the hobby is going to keep hobbiest entheused. Lovely model.

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 7:23 am
by Rufus T. Firefly
Disco? Not at all.....hard rock near metal riffs and a huge improvement over the usual insipid faux country rubbish that somehow has gotten associated with model train video.

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 10:32 am
by SWrailroader
OK, hard rock, but the lighting is Disco IMO.

I have a couple USH NYC H-10s that are near mint and almost as nice and purchased for about $500. Given the proven durability of USH pieces not sure I would consider the SS pieces, maybe P&LE version.

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 10:51 am
by healey36
I don't know...a bit of Donna Summer might be terrific.

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 11:50 am
by up148
I like the oldies from the 50's and 60's (some 70's). I like some jazz and even classical. Disco had a cool beat and Donna Summer was the queen, but I burned out early. The older music is just timeless for me.

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:35 pm
by Pacific Limited
Disco, you mean as in Travolta and the image of a dance floor, bell bottoms, big collars, Elvis suit and reflecting, glowing, spinning, sparkling disco-balls?, the music is nothing like any disco IMHO. Sounds more like most popular music now, processed for smart phone speakers, dead flat, no life but a wall of noise. Likely production work in AI, and 32 tracks of digital AI generated goodness mixed down in some kid's parent's basement in Iowa.

I passed on. Thumb-scrolled on from that one. Ah, the life of a digital-influencer on social-platforming. If you eat the spoon fed bull being shoved up our rears, this is about the only career opportunity for GenZ left, online as sorority influencers. He needs more click-bait appeal. But give him credit, he is avoiding the dreaded fake AI voice narration and AI generated content. I believe the so-called "disco-shot" is real, no AI overlays.

Nice model, ok video. Its cool. I like it. Ill pass on the music.

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 5:27 pm
by Chris Webster
Rufus T. Firefly wrote:Disco? Not at all.....hard rock near metal riffs
I thought it was "thrash metal" but I'm not up to date with music labels.
SWrailroader wrote:I have a couple USH NYC H-10s that are near mint and almost as nice and purchased for about $500. Given the proven durability of USH pieces not sure I would consider the SS pieces, maybe P&LE version.
Brasstrains says the USH H10b engines were imported back in 1975, so those models are 51 years old - they've held up very well!

I don't own any 3rd Rail engines because I'm mostly interested in diesels and I just can't get past 3rd Rail's use of spinning drive shafts between the fuel tank and trucks.

Pacific Limited wrote:I passed on. Thumb-scrolled on from that one.
I only watch hobby videos in the 2X mode and most of them still take too long to watch.

That said, I recently came across this informative review:
Signal Light Productions - 3rd Rail Amtrak Chargers
It's too long, most of the review is about 3-railer problems but I still found it informative. At the 28 minute mark he shows how the models' screens are not screens at all and that interior lighting behind the screens only works in reverse. That was jarring to me because I've been seeing the prototypes often and the lit up screens really stand out at night. He also shows how the sound is wrong and explains why he'll be installing Blunami in his models. That last part made me understand why Blunami is becoming so popular with the 3railers.

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 8:59 am
by Rufus T. Firefly
healey36 wrote:I don't know...a bit of Donna Summer might be terrific.


Been listening to a lot of St. Vincent lately......and some live Blue Oyster Cult from the 80's, :wink: :wink:

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 9:37 am
by up148
I have Pandora on my phone and several Bose Revolve bluetooth speakers in rooms of the house. At normal listening volumns these speakers and many other BT speakers have amazing sound for their size.

But, I've been adding Santana as a favorite and I'm hearing songs I never knew. The man is a virtuoso and under rated IMHO.

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:40 am
by Rufus T. Firefly
up148 wrote:I have Pandora on my phone....


On my Kindle along with Progzilla radio, but what I tend to listen to through that system is Star's End from XPN radio plugged into the stereo and then into my office and shop - matched pairs of JBL speakers.

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 11:35 am
by Pacific Limited
I have a Sony nw-wm1am2 DAP with my PCM files, none of them below 16bit. I also maintain a substantial digital archive with a musical heritage group in my genre and have personally migrated 1000's of master analog sources to 16-28 bit PCM format. As far as sourcing from "CD", I have extracted in excess of 40,000 16 bit audio files from them. My DAP supports 2TB micro-SD cards and I get my audio as close to analog as one can do next to bringing 10" reels or vinyl in my pocket can get.

Hi-Res Bluetooth is pretty good, I have phones that amaze me how superlative it is. But I much prefer wired phones through 1/4 jack. As far as the wife's car, it has HiRes Bluetooth as well and its 1500 times better than any stream anywhere online, gimmicks included such as these supposed post op 4K BS processing of compression algorithms used by the Spotify's of the industry at a nominal subscription fee. I will never pay to play and not be able to archive. Never. New music is simply not available to us as consumers any longer. Despite that treasure, the record industry, its producers set these titles for smart phone speaker playback.

I miss analog, especially on FM when it was a beautiful thing on the local 100K stick running open reel automation from Shulkie Radio Productions (SRP), those beautiful BBC Midland Radio performances with the gentle sounds of the Great American Songbook. How I miss this era, we didnt know how good we had it. Even though most of you only had AM radios in the late 70s in your Oldsmobile, those that had HiFi in our homes late 60s to the 80s... digital added a layer, a tool to be able to successfully recreate what a man with a 10k Studer deck could revox on a system for all. Once you capture that analog in its purist form, done right, properly adjusted, digital can recite that up to a level that most of us mortals can never tell. Miracle. Like all great things, firstly in an attempt simply to save on storage, yes storage was and again thanks to data-center build out demand is high cost, the MP3 was born of necessity. I am not sure that was a good thing. The positive hype surrounding compression has been debunked and proven, by in large, AAC, you name it, is garbage. FLAC is OK, but still you can find artifacts irregardless of processing in FLAC, and even in CD 16 bit Wave files. The idea of any lower than that is pure theft to my ears. I prefer 28bit over 16bit in my PCM files. The prospect of going back to lossey streams I need to pay for? Dear Lawd.. no thank you. Besides, unlike most 20 somethings, I already had my music, its my life and what I play, I simply need move it too an infrastructure to playback in my pocket. Its available and a rather vibrant strong community much more than model Railroading. We love our music and no corporation is going to take it away from us over sanctions and profit models.

We've been dummmed-down in our availability to audio since the 10s, recording technology has made such huge progress since the 1930s, the 60s, 80s, and 00s, now we are between profit motives and control of intellectual property rights its been cut down by huge margins. A multi billion dollar investment by the record industry to get you to turn off the local celestial radio and stream at a subscription rate, and the complete inability to get anywhere near the sonic excellence that was captured by its creators.

It still amuses me beyond any descriptor, the intense hype that I read around compression algorithms and processing being feverishly developed by the subscription based streaming industry. Definitely a case of you will own nothing and be happy. Pay up.

Sad times. I am glad I have what I have. Anyone remember the CD buyback parties iTunes sponsored at your local music stores 25 years ago? Get your iTunes card, bring in all those unlicensed raw, full size 16bit Wave files embedded on optical media that likely would have out lived you. Come now you can't extract anymore profit from that old, out of date, obsolete tech... yeah, hurry up, we will shred those CDs for you and you can go download our AAC (sanctioned) version on the iTunes store, i might add with embedded malware that allows the industry to limit its bit depth, playback on devices, etc etc. -CONTROL.

You will own nothing and be happy. From my cold dead fingers, you will not take away my 28bit SACD Frank Sinatra captures from Capitol. No Sur!

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 11:43 am
by Pacific Limited
up148 wrote:I have Pandora on my phone and several Bose Revolve bluetooth speakers in rooms of the house. At normal listening volumns these speakers and many other BT speakers have amazing sound for their size.

But, I've been adding Santana as a favorite and I'm hearing songs I never knew. The man is a virtuoso and under rated IMHO.


I met the artist that did many of his album covers. Incredible, just like Santana's music. Cool beans Butch!

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 12:44 pm
by up148
I just like good music of almost any genre, as long as it's played and recorded well. Rediscoverd the Moody Blues several years back and although the music is not as hypnotizing as it was back in the day, they still hit the spot. Mike Pinder and his Melatron just blew me away.

Used to have different floor speakers and systems back in the 60's-70's and 80's....brands that were good, but no longer around. I wired our first new built hom in the early 90's for a B&O system, had wall controls and speakers in seveal rooms (how analog is that). Switched to Harmon Kardon (before they were bought out) a few years later and I think the sound was warmer without losing the high end to distortion.

But, I can't hear the high end any more longer (wonder why :lol: ), so blue tooth speakers do the job. Used to love hearing fingers moving up and down, from fret to fret. :(

Re: O scale brass review goes Disco

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 1:01 pm
by Rufus T. Firefly
Pacific Limited wrote:New music is simply not available to us as consumers any longer.


I'll disagree with you on that one - you might not have heard of Bandcamp. You might want to look/visit that site to find that it's direct to customer marketing of music most of which you can listen to prior to purchasing in a host of formats that frequently includes vinyl. Recently got the new albums from Stickmen as well as today a copy of their final concert from this year's tour that they sell at "name your price". While Stephen Thelan's Fractal Guitar series is fun listening, Markus Reuter's touch guitar stuff with Tony Levin's Chapman Stick is right up there with Stravinsky. In fact they covered Rite of Spring and used to play it in concert.

My hearing is not bad but it's nothing like it was 50 years ago when I was playing still......good enough is just that for me now - sound quality while running the bandsaw or while writing in my office is not all that concerning.