Page 1 of 5
Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Tue Dec 12, 2017 9:22 pm
by Seaboard Air Line Fan
I’ve got a hankerin to see what the stuff tastes like.
Never had any, so all you whiskey connoisseurs chime in with some suggestions

Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 3:46 am
by E7
Never drank any myself, but if you are going to fork over $40 for a fifth, I would hope whatever you purchased would be half decent. My poison of choice is Tequila, El Toro silver label or Cuervo silver.
Margarita: 2 shots tequila, 1 shot triple sec, 1 shot Rose's lime juice, margarita salt on the rim
Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 5:52 am
by robert.
Sample it in 1 ounce bottles first. My grandmother drank a spoon full of it everyday with her tea. She lived to 95.
Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 6:27 am
by Seaboard Air Line Fan
Thanks guys!
I’ve never had any and was wondering what it tastes like.
Tequila...years ago I was in school at Mare Island, my sister-in-law at the time was married and living nearby and I would visit her and her husband (tall Mexican fella) every weekend.
He had a friend that owned a bar, but didn’t have a liquor license so all he could legally sell was beer, but he kept liquor on hand to “give” to his friends.
Long story short, one of us ate the worm! I don’t recall if it was me but when I wokeup the next morning my head was in a trash can. It was years before I could even look at a bottle of Tequila without getting queasy
Good idea a Robert about the little bottles, thanks!
Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 8:32 am
by MurphOnMillerAve
I remember "learning", a few decades ago (in college) that the more sugar and the darker the color hard liquor had, the heavier and more punishing would the inevitable post-indulgence punishment be. The clearer, like vodka , the better for having a less abusive after-shock.
Maybe that's true ?
Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 9:02 am
by E7
It ALL makes for a nasty experience if you drink enough (as in "TOO MUCH") of it!

Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 9:57 am
by healey36
Rye whiskey is a Maryland thing. It went out of style many years ago and the local distillers vanished (except Pikesville, which has hung around a long time). Rye is all fashionable now, especially with Kevin Plank and his Sagamore Distillers coming on-line. However back in the post-prohibition 1930's it was the whiskey of choice around here. Rumor has it that it was what put Tallulah Bankhead, a Maryland girl, in the ground all those years ago.
Back when I worked downtown in Baltimore I used to occasionally catch up with a few friends over at the Owl Bar in the old Belvedere Hotel. The drink of choice was the Stone Fence (2 oz. of rye, a dash of bitters, topped off with apple cider). Great for this time of year but you can go blind quickly.
Pikesville, if you can find it, is probably a good bet if you're looking for something reasonably authentic. Probably $50 a bottle.
Healey
Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 10:07 am
by Seaboard Air Line Fan
The nearest ABC store does carry the Pikeville brand, thanks.
Crown Royal also makes Rye Whiskey.
Seems to be a number of well known distilleries that make it and a load of unheard of/startup distilleries that are making it. Canada seems to be growing Rye in abundance!
Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 11:05 am
by up148
E7 wrote:Never drank any myself, but if you are going to fork over $40 for a fifth, I would hope whatever you purchased would be half decent. My poison of choice is Tequila, El Toro silver label or Cuervo silver.
Margarita: 2 shots tequila, 1 shot triple sec, 1 shot Rose's lime juice, margarita salt on the rim
Damn, that should set you free after a couple of those.
Used to drink Long Island Teas and was quite adept and making them at home, using a shot of each of the 5 liquors required. A couple of those and you're feeling NO pain. Can't drink anymore due to medications, but I'd sure like too. Sometimes when I see a Guinness Stout advertisement I can almost taste it. It's a meal in a bottle!
BH
Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 11:07 am
by MurphOnMillerAve
Not to be a killjoy, but doesn't every single ounce of alcohol burn-out brain cells?
Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 11:59 am
by Seaboard Air Line Fan
MurphOnMillerAve wrote:Not to be a killjoy, but doesn't every single ounce of alcohol burn-out brain cells?
Yeah, but your system flushes those dead cells out and soon you’re as good as new
At 66+ I think 1 sip every now and then will do more good than harm, as long as a person doesn’t become the bottles titty baby.
Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 1:50 pm
by MurphOnMillerAve
Now, there's an expression I am going to remember, "..the bottle's titty baby." !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! In three words, an instant picture forms!
Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 2:02 pm
by up148
Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 2:10 pm
by MurphOnMillerAve
up148 wrote:MurphOnMillerAve wrote:Not to be a killjoy, but doesn't every single ounce of alcohol burn-out brain cells?
whasa bran sell...da sheet donut boder mi bran sells. ....
BH
Well said!

Re: Best $40 Rye Whiskey?
Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 2:13 pm
by Rufus T. Firefly
MurphOnMillerAve wrote:Not to be a killjoy, but doesn't every single ounce of alcohol burn-out brain cells?
I'd be more worried about brain cell loss from watching TV