Rufus T. Firefly wrote:up148 wrote: Loathed book reports.
As did I. My position was that if you wanted to know what the book was about, go read it yourself!
But, I can remember feeling so sorry for a few classmates who could hardly spell, much less read, even in higher grades. Always thought the teachers did them a disservice passing them to the next grade. It affected and handicapped their entire life.
Basic reading and writing & spelling. I've never understood
the willful resistance to learning or teaching the same.
The open disdain for this truly basic area competency continues to be hard to accept.
I would offer the observation, as a teacher of English since 1969, that NOT, or rarely, finding consistencies in the rhyme-or-reason of the English language is at the root of the difficulty; for example, but not restricted to:
roots, prefixes, words, and
suffixes from the following (and many requiring unique pronunciations):
+Latin (ex. cred, in
credence; credulous; accredit. )
+Greek (ex. phobia, in
acrophobia; claustrophobia.)
+French (ex.
debacle; faux pas; liaison' a la carte; encore; vignette; cuisine; boutique; corsage; naïve; nonchalant...)
+Italian (ex.
tenor; soprano; pizza; fiasco; vendetta; gusto; gondola; portfolio...)
+Spanish (ex.
renegade; junta; aficionado; adobe; bonanza; canyon; mustang...)
+Anglo-Saxon (ex. "a" , as in:
aboard; afoul; aloof;); with, as in: withdraw; withhold; withstand.)
+mythology (ex.
Adonis; hector; ambrosial; Draconian.)
Then there is the whole complicated aspect in English of
silent vowels;
double vowels;
final "e"; variety in vowel sounds; shall we teach
Phonics, at all, as a deliberate skill-set;
diphthongs; consonant sounds varying or silent; accent and syllabication; vowel sounds affected by "r"; digraphs, to name a few of the special foci.
These many examples, out of very many, resist being able to tell the student a certain way of saying a word or part of a word will always be the same and that they can depend on such helpful patterns. Ex. "gh" in
laugh; ghost. Ex. varying sound for
"s": he
rs; kis
s. Such examples seem easy to tell or list, but the teacher has to also say, "But the sound will change, depending on...etc." Students like consistency. They are not going to get it when learning English. The entire language is made up of INconsistencies and exceptions in the sounds of every single letter and combinations of letters.
Furthermore, Italian, French, Greek, and Spanish have very consistent pronunciation rules and customs in use of language, which are very clear. But this is not true of English, which as you can see, is composed of several disparate language imports into its word bank.
Add to that mix, students who are hyper-active, disruptive (for attention), or not active at all, resistant, and/or uncooperative, and frustration can set in very quickly, both among the students and as well within the teachers. Teaching is not easy, nor is being a consistently successful student. If ever there were an under-appreciated profession and skill, it is teaching, notwithstanding all the smart-aleck experts out there in a personal know-it-all fog who are very, very sure they know the absolute best for every student on Earth.
Now, wasn't that fun?
